An example of this would be othello, which has been remade into a movie called o. The movie o was a more modernized remake version of shakespeares othello. The o movie is a modification of othello by william shakespeare and is set in the 20th century in a high school, where odin in contrast to othello is a star basketball star and dating desi, desdemona in the play. With these significant differences in daily life, come the attempts of movie creators to help prevent our modern day tragedies.
This translation of the original broadway play have many of the same characteristics as the original version such as. There is a particularly fine movie of othello made in 1922. Home essay samples literature othello othello and o the movie. This is the first cinematic reproduction of the play released by a major studio that casts an african american actor to play the role of othello, although lowbudget. It was filmed in charleston, south carolina in the spring of 1999. Compare movie and play othello many shakespearean plays have been utilized by hollywood. Desi julia stiles loves him and is faithful to him, but he cannot bring himself to trust her, and that is his downfall. The movies character roger is chided as a faggot while shakespeares rodrigo acts like an adolescent in love, speaking of suicide at the loss of the desdemona he never had the chance to love. Many characters in o have a counterpart to othello. Othello goes to high school, welsh 225 is an accurate description of the movie o as directed by tim blake nelson.
Comparison of o and othello o and lawrence fishburnes othello are both contemporary film interpretations of shakespeares othello. The main difference in the two narratives of o and othello is nelsons choice of setting, in time and geographic locationa modernera prep school, a hiphop soundtrack, and a plethora of profanity portray these tragic series of events as occurring in the present time. However, they were transferred into different situations and setting. Essay on a comparison of othello and the movie o 1548 words. The movie o has those same characteristics with the characters roles.
Tim blake nelson has creatively restructured othello into a film to appeal to a teenage audience. Othello comparisoncontrast by brittany washington on prezi. A christian moor and general of the armies of venice, othello is an eloquent and physically powerful figure, respected by all those around him. Othellos aide iago kenneth branagh, jealous over the elevation of his rival, cassio nathaniel parker, the directors reallife brother to lieutenant, begins scheming to make othello believe. This movie, shelved over two years due to the epidemic of high school shootings in the late 1990s, is an attempt to take in hand these disasters caused by peer pressure and jealousy kurnit. Othello goes to high school, welsh, 225 is an accurate description of the movie o as directed by tim blake nelson. Genre cpmarison for the movie o and shakespeares play othello. Othello is a 1995 american drama film based on william shakespeares tragedy of the same name. His supposed friend hugo josh hartnett plants the seeds of doubt, suggesting desi is secretly sleeping with another student, michael.
The film o consist of many similar elements from the original play, othello. O 2001 12 out of four after the disastrous attempts the last decade has made at updating shakespeare, i eventually thought that it was nearly impossible to successfully modernize anything of the genre. What details were kept from the original script, and which ones were changed to reflect the modern culture. The play is a tragedy about two starcrossed young lovers whose deaths eventually reconciled their feuding families. A basketball court at a private southern high school replaces othello s battlefield, and mekhi phifer as odin o portrays the role of our tragic hero othello, while julia stiles as desi plays the innocent desdemona, josh hartnett as hugo plays our envious and machiavellian villain iago. Are these the 10 best shakespeare screen adaptations. Compare and contrast the play othello with the movie o. Shakespeares othello and the film, parkers othello. The similarities between them make o an excellent rendition of the original.
Both movies are uniform in the recreation of william shakespeares original play of othello. Comparisons of shakespeares othello and the movie o essay. This is not an example of the work written by professional essay writers. The movie has matching character with the book like in the book is othello but in the movie is odin james, iago is hugo goulding, cassio is michael cassio, desdemona is desi brable, emilia is emily, roderigo is roger roderiguez, brabantio is dean bob brable and bianca is brandy. The movie o is the modern rendition of shakespeares classic tragedy othello. Find imdb of these, the 1952 orson welles version is probably the most famous, for its convoluted production history and the genius of welles. Look up two or three cases involving recent teen suicides caused by bullying cyber or otherwise. For me, i think o movie was a god modernday translation of othello by william shakespeare. This movie, shelved over two years due to the epidemic show more content. Odin mekhi phifer, a talented black athlete, the only black student in the school, is in love with desi julia stiles, the headmasters daughter.
The similarities between the movie o and shakespeares othello leave no question as to the heritage of this updated production. In spite of his elevated status, he is nevertheless easy prey to insecurities because of his age, his life as a soldier, and his race. Apr 22, 2011 nelsons movie, o, came out in 2001, starring mekhi phifer as odin othello, julia stiles as desi desdemona, and josh hartnett as hugo iago. Othello comes to venice to lead them against the turks. A comparison of othello and the movie o when shakespeare composed the tragedy othello televisions were not. Othello differences and similarities of the movie and play. Analysis of adaptation othello 1995 by oliver parker. O essays many shakespearean plays have been used by hollywood. Along with no televisions, life in the late 1500s had many different qualities than it does today. O the movie portrays the main characters in various similarities and differences. Choices in the movie o a young boy named hugo feels neglected by his father causing him to twist the minds of friends and family making it easy for him to get revenge on odin a basketball player who he feels receives more attention from his father then he does. Differentces and similarities of the movie othello and the. Odin to othello, desi to desdemona, hugo to iago, emily to emilia, roger to roderigo, and michel to cassio. Compare and contrast o movie and othello 788 words.
Othello 1995 directed by oliver parker is an excellent adaptation of william shakespeares the tragedy of othello, the moor of venice. O othello movie analysis and summary schoolworkhelper. Shakespeares themes and ideas can still relate with many aspects of society today, but seldom do filmmakers incorporate modern culture with the timeless stories told so long ago. Especially just at this moment of the films 1995 release, with the fates of o.
Macbeth, starring michael fassbender and marion cotillard, joins kenneth branaghs hamlet and orson welless chimes at midnight in my top. The moorish general othello is manipulated into thinking that his new wife desdemona has been carrying on an affair with his lieutenant michael cassio, when in reality, it is all part of the scheme of a bitter ensign named iago. They both have many differences as well as similarities. A basketball court at a private southern high school replaces othellos battlefield, and mekhi phifer as odin o portrays the role of our tragic hero othello, while julia stiles as desi plays the innocent desdemona, josh hartnett as hugo plays our envious and machiavellian villain iago. The movie o starts off showing odin receiving an award in front of the rest of the school for the most valuable basketball player. May 10, 2015 othello 1995 directed by oliver parker is an excellent adaptation of william shakespeares the tragedy of othello, the moor of venice. Dec 07, 2007 the movie o, released on august 31, 2001, is a retelling of shakespeares othello set in a college prepatory school. In the play othello there are two characters that make the play what it is. Odin to othello, desi to desdemona, hugo to iago, emily. Even thought, the movie departs from the original play, due to the cutting of many dialogues, and an addition of new scenes, still this infusion of the authors vision and shakespearean genius not only changes a common perspective of the play, but. Compare and contrast o movie and othello 788 words bartleby. A version of the play othello written by william shakespeare that appeals to teens i. Oct 10, 2012 othello and o the movie o by tim blake nelson is based on shakespeares play othello. Comparative study between othello and o the movie essay sample.
Shakespeares play othello vs nelsons film o english literature. Comparisons between the play othello and the movie o. O the main differences between the play and movie although the movie o is a production based on shakespe atomic number 18s othello, several differences follow between the two such as womens brotherly status, iagos personality change, and the type of language employed by the characters. Comparison othello play and film english literature essay. Nelsons 2000 movie production of o shows differences as well as similarities to the original. Essay on a comparison of othello and the movie o 1548. That sexuality also comes into play in the use of the fantasy sequences in which othello dreams of finding desdemona and cassio together in bed. Nelsons movie, o, came out in 2001, starring mekhi phifer as odin othello, julia stiles as desi desdemona, and josh hartnett as hugo iago.
In the 2004 movie version of the phantom of the opera gerard butler plays the phantom, emmy rossum plays christine, and patrick wilson plays raoul. We live in a world entangled with lies, jealousy, violence and tragedy. What is the difference between the othello movie and play. A comparison of othello and the movie o 1551 words 123 help me. It contains many different styles of music, ranging from rap to opera. A comparison of othello and the movie o 1551 words 123. The similarities between the movie o and shakespeares othello leave. In the production o the main characters position in society does not truly capture the same importance as it did in othello. That would certainly be one big contrast if that happens to be the movie you are talking about. Othello and iago are both military men with strong fighting abilities. The themes and ideas of shakespeare williams were translated to the movie and that he will agree with the modernization.
Newer directors are always trying to make this story into a movie about contemporary suburban white high schools because they can work some soft core scenes of a black kid and a white girl in erotic situations, some rap music, and present the. Movie, o cannot compare to shakespeares othello 123 help me. Two texts that portray these values of society include othello, a play written by william shakespeare and o, a film directed by tim blake nelson. Romeo and juliet is one of the many plays written by william shakespeare. The play othello was about a noble moor, othello that was in love with a woman named desdemona.
Even though hes the only black student at the elite palmetto grove academy, he has the adoration of all, including the teams coach and the deans beautiful daughter, desi. The movie continues to show scenes of othello and desdemona having intercourse. It stars mekhi phifer, julia stiles, and josh hartnett. Othello and o the movie o by tim blake nelson is based on shakespeares play othello.
Comparative study between othello and o the movie literature. The same trap is laid for the main character in both versions and the same amount of casualties happens in both final scenes. Othello and iago are both military men with strong fighting abilities however. O is a 2001 american drama film, and a modern adaptation of william shakespeares othello, set in an american high school.
The characters of othello and iago are tangled in the deception between love and hate. It still contains the same central ideas which are racism, jealousy. The movie o, released on august 31, 2001, is a retelling of shakespeares othello set in a college prepatory school. Nelsons o is heavily based on shakespeares original but is set in a modern setting, with high school students playing the roles crafted by shakespeare. To some degree, any modern production must make iago the villain and othello the victim, and suffer as a result. I m going to compare and contrast the characters, plot and setting from the book and movie to prove my point. May 25, 2018 home essay samples literature othello othello and o the movie. At this point, both it and the 1967 version with lawrence ol. It was directed by tim blake nelson and written by brad kaaya. We are an envious society that never has enough, and were willing to tear down others to get what we want, or to ruin their happiness. O the main differences between the play and movie although the movie o is a production based on shakespe atomic number 18s othello, several differences follow between the two such as womens brotherly status, iagos personality change. To be jealous has to do with or arose from feelings of envy, apprehension, or bitterness. Written in 1604, it has spanned a total of 12 movie adaptations othello, including the 2001 version directed by tim blake nelson. This is i believe a way to modernize the version to appeal to another audience.
This time period had no war on drugs and no high school shootings. O is odin james, a star high school basketball player and nba hopeful. With laurence fishburne, kenneth branagh, irene jacob, nathaniel parker. Othello differences and similarities of the movie and. Shakespeares play othello vs nelsons film o english. Romeo, one of the main characters is a montague and juliet the other main character is a capulet.
Some similarities that both the movie and play focus on are themes of racial tension, jealousy, manipulation, small props, and much more. The two main characters in the play othello are othello and iago. O 2001, the merchant of venice 2004, the proposition 1998, romeo and juliet 1968, hamlet 2000. Delmar from o brother directs this takeoff on othello, perhaps the th movie remake of this story. The film of othello by william shakespeare 1179 words cram. O is a retelling of shakespeares othello, set in a contemporary southern prep school.